I don't know about those bikes, but hi, and welcome! Have you test ridden them yet? If the fit is good, the hard part is done. You might also want to try a few other bikes, even if you think they're "too much bike" for you, just for comparison's sake.
We have a lot of Cannondale lovers around here, so even though I've never ridden one, I'm going to suggest checking them out. And Specialized, of course, since my first bike was a Dolce, and what I fell in love with cycling on.
'02 Eddy Merckx Fuga, Selle An Atomica
'85 Eddy Merckx Professional, Selle An Atomica
'10 Soma Double Cross DC, Selle An Atomica
Slacker on wheels.