I'm looking at a 2007 Specialized Dolce Comp Compact for 900..is that a good price?

Also, a 2010 Trek 1.5 for 1000 and 2010 Dolce Elite Compact for 1200 and Trek 2.1 Compact for 1250.
As far as these three go, i like the look of the Trek better, but the LBS that sells Specialized better.

I've been test riding them to try to get a feel for them and am about even as far as the 2010 bikes go.

I'm going back to try them again, but...Any thoughts or suggestions?