I would replace it, specially if you'll be commuting (replied in your other thread)
My helmet is from '02, and I've always thought it's best to replace every 4-6 years, as the polyurethane breaks down after awhile.
I'm in the market for a new one as well...but I'm a poor college student so I'm just looking at an Indicator.



I am a recreational rider who is just getting back into getting my fat butt on a bike 
Reply With Quote