Fear, fear, fear, plain old fear to clip and unclip. Advice please!

[Catrin]

Keep practicing and make certain those pedals are adjusted as loose as possible. SPD's aren't my favorite, but a lot of people do like them. Since you've been riding platforms for so long it is just going to take time to re-train your muscle memory about how to stop. Just try to anticipate when you will need to stop and be intentional about your movements.

Penny4, with SPD pedals at least, you automatically unclip when you fall, it just happens. I fell LOTS when I was learning how to use SPDs the first time and both feet always just unclipped on their own. This may not be true for all pedals, I did have this (not) happen once with my Speedplay Frogs, but that may have been an anomaly.

[Maye]

Keep practicing and make certain those pedals are adjusted as loose as possible. SPD's aren't my favorite, but a lot of people do like them. Since you've been riding platforms for so long it is just going to take time to re-train your muscle memory about how to stop. Just try to anticipate when you will need to stop and be intentional about your movements.

Penny4, with SPD pedals at least, you automatically unclip when you fall, it just happens. I fell LOTS when I was learning how to use SPDs the first time and both feet always just unclipped on their own. This may not be true for all pedals, I did have this (not) happen once with my Speedplay Frogs, but that may have been an anomaly.

Hi Catrin,
Thanks for the advice. I have read a couple of your threads when you where trying to find the perfect pedals for your road bike. How many you tried and for how long after you find the Speedplay Frogs? I have read so many things about the Speedplay Frog and Lights that I'm tempted to give them a try. Thanks in advance!

[Crankin]

Remember, Speedplay Frogs are mountain bike pedals, with recessed cleats.
Speedplay Light Action are road pedals, with cleats that are not recessed. You need cleat covers for walking in the shoes, which some people don't like.
I've been using Speedplay X pedals (road pedals) for around 7 years. I love them and frankly, I don't walk around that much when riding my bike with these pedals; walking into a lunch stop, or using a restroom. I have Frogs on my other bike, which is a road bike, but is used more for slower/touring rides/vacation/shopping and errands, going out to eat, etc. They actually were harder for me to get used to (not clipping in or out), in that I found myself unclipping "accidentally," which caused some issues. From what I've heard, the newer Frogs do have this tendency, if you aren't clipped in all of the way, and sometimes it's a bit hard to hear the "click" with these pedals. They are broken in now, and I've trained myself to really be aware of my foot position, so this doesn't happen. I previously used spds on my hybrid and mountain bikes, and they really caused me to have knee pain. This is why I got the Frogs, because they are free floating.

[Catrin]

Hi Catrin,
Thanks for the advice. I have read a couple of your threads when you where trying to find the perfect pedals for your road bike. How many you tried and for how long after you find the Speedplay Frogs? I have read so many things about the Speedplay Frog and Lights that I'm tempted to give them a try. Thanks in advance!

I love my Speedplay Frogs, but as Crankin pointed out, they are indeed mountain bike pedals. The recessed cleats make it much easier to walk around, and eventually I will use them on my mountain bike...or not. The bottom line is there isn't anything wrong with using mountain bike pedals on the road and you will find differing opinions. My knees LOVE the free floating Frogs, which is why I have them.

I've only tried SPD pedals outside of the Frogs. There are a couple of others that I might like to try someday (Time in particular), but it is an investment to change pedals and I see no reason to fix what isn't broken Speedplay is going to release another version of a mountain bike pedal (with adjustable float) later this year, but they have no plans to stop production on Frogs. Whewww!

I've never had a problem unclipping by accident with my Frogs, and never a problem clipping in. I do "pull up" on my second foot once I am going to make certain it is clipped in all the way but haven't had a problem with it to date.

I don't know anything about road pedals so I can't advise on those

[Bethany1]

I think the hardest part for me was clipping in. The dang things would flip over and over as I'd try to get my shoes in making for dangerous weaves and panic would set in.

I've tried several kinds. One with platforms on side, mountain bike (have them on both sides) and road ones. The road ones were the worst to get in/out of.

I gave up and use the cheapie pedals as I was tired of crashing.

Part of me would like to give it another try, but I don't want to kill myself trying to get the cleats to fit into the pedals while it flips around.

[ny biker]

I think the hardest part for me was clipping in. The dang things would flip over and over as I'd try to get my shoes in making for dangerous weaves and panic would set in.

I've tried several kinds. One with platforms on side, mountain bike (have them on both sides) and road ones. The road ones were the worst to get in/out of.

I gave up and use the cheapie pedals as I was tired of crashing.

Part of me would like to give it another try, but I don't want to kill myself trying to get the cleats to fit into the pedals while it flips around.

Before you start moving, have one foot clipped in. For me it's the left foot, because I always clip out first and step on the ground with my right foot. Have the bike in an easy gear.

Have the clipped-in foot near the top of the pedal stroke, around 2:00. Starting high gives you more momentum from the first stroke.

As you push the pedal with the clipped-in foot, slide your butt onto the saddle. This is important -- you are much more stable while you are seated.

While continuing the pedal stroke with the clipped-in foot, clip in your other foot. If you miss the first try, that's okay, because you're seated and you got a decent amount of momentum from that first clipped-in stroke. If necessary, you can pedal around again with that clipped-in foot (which is easier to do since you're in an easy gear) so you can try again with the other foot.

Once you're riding, as you approach an intersection or anyplace where it looks like you'll have to clip out, shift to an easier gear so you'll be ready when you start up again.

As mentioned before, practicing on an indoor trainer and on a grassy field helps a lot. There's no traffic to worry about and falling on the grass is much better than falling on pavement.

[Jo-n-NY]

I just switched from Speedplay Frogs to Light Action after 7 years. I got the Frogs for one reason, they were highly liked here on the forum especially to someone new to clippless. There is no spring so you just turn your foot and out you come. I never accidently clipped out. Clipping in was effortless. And yes I had mtn bike shoes as others have mentioned.

I just switched to the Speedplay Light Actions because I wanted a roadshoe for my new bike. As of now although ready to switch over, I have them on the bike I use on the trainer to get use to them only because I am not good with change. But they really are not difficult to clip out of. I just have to give a little umf when I turn where like as I mentioned with the frogs there was no resistance.

[Jo-n-NY]

BTW...my husband says to no matter whether you are a lefty or righty, always clip out on the right away from traffic in case of falling over for one reason or another. That is just his suggestion that he tells his customers.