I had the Fuji Finest 2.0- similar frame but with slightly lower components. I rode it about 6000 miles, but when I was ready to replace it, I discovered it didn't fit me nearly as well as the bike I replaced it with. I think it was fine for me as a starter bike, and I rode as far as 72 miles on it. I have no experience with the Scott.

I'm sure it might be worth trying the steel frame to compare the comfort compared to the alloy, if there is one available.