Tall riders and WSD fit?

[jlnc]

Interesting Owlie about the WSD and unisex specs being the same. I don't really know much about all of the #'s, but I looked at the specs on trek's website, and you are correct, all of the measurements seemed to be the same between the Lexa and 2.1 in a 56. I think the 2.1 i test rode was actually a 58. I think the Lexa was an H3 fit (most relaxed) and the 2.1 is H2 (more aggressive), so that might make a difference.
If Roo is 5'9 and on a 56, do you think it is feasible that I am also comfortable on a 56 (at 5'11)?
Given that I am new to road bikes, and the position is very different, it's hard to know if it feels ok.

[jessmarimba]

If Roo is 5'9 and on a 56, do you think it is feasible that I am also comfortable on a 56 (at 5'11)?
Given that I am new to road bikes, and the position is very different, it's hard to know if it feels ok.

Perfectly feasible. My younger sister and I are the same height, but she rides a 51 cm frame and I'm comfortable on 54. There are so many different measurements that go into determining what bikes fit what people.

Sometimes determining the "perfect" bike is difficult, because you need adjustments or parts swapped that a shop may not think to tell you about...but definitely listen to your gut about what bikes feel absolutely wrong. Keep the maybes on your list, but keep a record of what about them felt odd to you. Then make sure you bring those issues up before you put any money on the table. If the shop wants to keep you as a customer, they'll help alleviate your concerns and not just brush them off.

[Koronin]

Go with what you feel best on. I just bought a 48cm Felt F5 (men's frame) and love it. Actually my husband is getting the 51cm Felt F5. His is actually the floor model.
I'm 5'0" and also have a hard time finding anything in my size on at a shop. Most shops would have to special order for me. I've only been able to test two bikes that were floor models. One was the base model Lexa at our old LBS in Charlotte. The other was a Dolce at a dealer in Raleigh. My old road bike is a Trek 2000 47cm men's bike. Basically what I discovered in testing the two WSD bikes is that I prefer the fit of the men's bike, but will never be able to find the small size in a floor model to test. The older bike shop is of the opinion that I'm female so I have to have a WSD, even though I'm not as comfortable on them. The new bike shop in town listened to what I was telling them. (The new bike shop sells Specialized and Felt) Basically as far as their two brands decided that I needed to either look at the Felt 5 series or the Specialized Ameria (mostly because the Allez does not come in a small enough frame size for me.)

[out_spokin']

I'm 5'10" and a 56 is almost like a toy bike to me, so yeah, it's all about leg and torso length. If you can afford a fit from a recommended fitter in your area, I'd do it (so much less than the loss if your new bike isn't right!). Regardless, for sure go on a couple of long test rides before committing, and if there's another shop or two to try, I highly recommend thinking outside the Trek/Specialized box. Especially if you don't need/want a WSD bike, you may find a shop who will take more time and care with you. Or not...but have fun!

[Bethany1]

I have a WSD Trek Mamba 29er Mountain bike and DH has the same size in men's. There are some differences but not much. My handlebars are smaller and I think the top tube is sloped differently. Love the WSD design on my Mamba much better than his men's Mamba but not sure what makes the difference.

I'm 5'10" and ride a 56cm Trek Madone but at times it seems too small. It's not WSD though. Seems that size is hard to find. My son has an Allez that's bigger (can't remember size but it's HUGE) and almost fits me better. I think Specialized makes more comfortable frames but I get frustrated with the gearing problems. Their Tarmac was to die for in comfort. I'd almost wished I bought that bike instead of the Madone.

LBS I went to in Lincoln had a WSD Madone that was small and when I asked about the differences, he said the larger WSD sizes are basically the same size as the regular ones. I sat on the WSD (too bad it was too small) and it felt really nice so again there has to be some kind of difference.

If it feels good to ride it regardless of size or WSD, go for it. I wish I could try a WSD 56 Madone to compare to mine, but I'd have to order it on condition I buy it.

Try out different brands as well. A 56 in one company may not be a 56 in another. If a 58 fits better, do it.

I know the guy said there wasn't much of a difference between the larger sizes of bikes, but there is. I take my Madone in for a fitting with this guy on Tuesday. He said some minor changes would really help with comfort once I explained some of the issues.

So yes, tall people can use WSD bikes if needed. They are just harder to find because they aren't in demand. I wouldn't change my WSD Mamba for anything.

Good luck with shopping for your bike. Take your time so you don't get overwhelmed.

[jlnc]

Thanks for all the feedback everyone. I went out on Sunday and went to 3 more shops and did more test rides on various sizes/brands, but didn't find anything I was too interested in.
I went back to my LBS tonight for another test ride on teh 56 Lexa. The awesome sales guy who helped me with my FX last year was there tonight. Good news...he had a 58 Lexa (I guess the other sales guy didn't know it was there on Saturday), so i could compare the 56 and 58 Lexa. The 58 felt better and the reach was good. It was a 2011, on sale....what's a girl to do??? A few accessories later...she was mine!
Not sure how to post pics, but it is the 2011 Lexa SLX, 58, in the black/white/blue color, with a subtle flower patter in it. Love it, can't wait to get out and ride it!

[pll]

w00t! Congratulations!

[Koronin]

Congrats!