Recently, as I was trying to decide between 5 (yes, i could narrow the list down to 5!) new road bikes, 3 of which, I could not testride, I brought all the different geometries (printed out from online) to a professional fitter to discuss. He got me on the size cycle and we looked at all the geometries and talked about the kind of riding I do and by the end, the list was down to 2. then, it was all about paintjob

in your case, i think both of these are quite different geometries (head tube lenght, etc.) so, along with everybody else, I agree that the one that fits best, will be the best for you.

goodluck!

julie