I really like the bar end shifting - but I've never used STI so I can't really compare. For me it's just a natural motion.

There's nothing wrong with matching bikes. Thom and I both ride 54 Rambouillets. I got mine first. He got his when Grant was selling his demo stock. Thom actually bought the bike I test rode. Brooks saddles are wonderful. I have the green one with the titanium rails. Thom's got an older one on his. It's a much longer saddle. His bike is the trainer, and if I sit back on his saddle I'm too far back and it bothers my knees. Sliding forward a little takes care of it though.

Whatever bike you decide on Jo, enjoy the ride!

Veronica