Chamois

[nscrbug]

I've never liked leg warmers, but I know a lot of people who wear and like them. I can't otherwise imagine wearing tights under my cycling shorts. Like you, I wear my shorts under my tights. I hate having two waistbands binding me. Neither are tight on their own, but together I find them uncomfortable. I'm thinking about investing in a pair of padded tights. I otherwise like knickers for days that are cool, but not cold.

X100!!! This is what I have gone to wearing on cold rides (padded tights), because I could not stand having two waistbands digging into my tummy. I especially HATE drawstrings! Late last season, I discovered a pair of PI Elite Thermal Cycling tights (with the Elite 3D pad) that have a wonderfully comfortable WIDE waistband that stays up on me without the use of a dreaded drawstring. It is now my go-to tight that I've been wearing until it gets warm enough for knickers or shorts.

[malkin]

I'm ok with more layers if the outside ones are a bigger size-- big enough to look ridiculous on me without layers underneath.

[zoom-zoom]

Late last season, I discovered a pair of PI Elite Thermal Cycling tights (with the Elite 3D pad) that have a wonderfully comfortable WIDE waistband that stays up on me without the use of a dreaded drawstring. It is now my go-to tight that I've been wearing until it gets warm enough for knickers or shorts.

I'm glad you posted this. I have the same tights without the chamois and I HATE the drawstring and wearing them over a pair of shorts. I think that is contributing to my crotch issues.

[ny biker]

I had a couple of pairs of shorts that came with a drawstring. I pulled the drawstring out. It's not necessary.

But anyway. Regarding the OP, if you wear unpadded tights under bike shorts, you'll probably wind up with seams in painful places. To me, preventing pain is more important than the way tights-over-shorts looks.

Chamois tights under chamois shorts would also be painful. Too much bunching of fabric and padding would lead to chafing.

[Crankin]

I've never had an issue with wearing tights over cycling shorts. My shorts don't have drawstrings and if tights come with one, I pull it out, if they are tight enough without it. Maybe I am just used to that "tight" feeling?
As far as the leg warmers go, I can only wear mine with my Terry Bella shorts. The high amount of lycra holds them up well and the shorts are longer than my Shebeest S Pros. I also bought leg warmers that are for women, that come in actual sizes, from Sheila Moon. That's what really helped.