first crash... do I need to replace my shoes?

[aicabsolut]

The only thing I can think of is that you stripped the threads. Since the cleat was screwed into a separate plate, then I'd think the only thing you could have stripped would be the threads in the screw holes on that plate. (BTW if you damage the ones in your shoes, they are likely replaceable). Unless you had some kind of impact to a non-replaceable part of the shoe (such as breaking a carbon sole), then the shoes should be fine.

I'm the most concerned with why your cleat didn't release before being ripped off the plate. It's not that uncommon to break a composite cleat with the right kind of fall, but I've never seen Speedplays do what yours did.

[loopybunny]

Thanks for all of the input on this issue.

I need to play with the float on the new cleats before I can get out and ride again. I didn't realize until late this afternoon that I don't have a tiny screwdriver and didn't think to ask while at the shop.

I'm eager to get back out though. I have a ride in less than 2 weeks and it's really important that I'm prepared to hold onto the group for more than a few seconds.