Moms, childhood issues, and certified letters

[malkin]

But let me offer this: People whose issues with their parents are minimal, won't have anything useful from their own experience to offer you. People whose issues with their parents are significant, will have too much of an overlay from their own experience to have anything useful to offer you.
(

I'm in the second group, so all I can do is send is my best wishes to you.

[TrekTheKaty]

Yes, that is the important message. We want you to know you are not alone. And take care of #1 (yourself) first. As women, we tend to not do that. I send happy thoughts your way for Mardi Gras

[MartianDestiny]

Withm,

I have to voice some respectful disagreement with your post. Words and sentiments like these spoken to me in person (as I did not discuss anything on the internet when all of this was occurring to me) really added a lot of pain and heartache to what was already a very gutwrenching, life altering, and exceptionally painful drawn out decision process. And, yes, added to bouts of depression and even occasional suicidal thoughts that I was luckily able to (in time, and with the help of some very close friends) overcome (and not act on). Similar sentiments made me keep working at an emotionally abusive, manipulative relationship longer than I probably would have otherwise (after all she was/is "my mother" and I couldn't possibly just erase her from my life without being a horrible, rotten, ungrateful child). (and let me reiterate that this was a very painful process for me that took YEARS of consideration, attempts at a relationship (on any level), realization that I was indeed NOT a horrible person, etc. none of which was ever taken lightly; I most certainly didn't get angry with her in one conversation and walk off in a huff never to speak with her again.)

Yes, parents will always be our parents, and we can't change that "like it or not". That doesn't mean one is obligated to bend to their every whim, need, objection to one's life, or other quark; especially not at the expense of their own mental (and sometimes unfortunately physical) health. More obligated to put forth an effort than if they were some random person you met once, of course. I don't think anyone takes damaging, ending, or ignoring a relationship with their parent(s) lightly or really needs to be reminded that the person is indeed their parent and thus should be of more importance than a street acquaintance.

The implications demonize the victim/child, as if they clearly are not trying hard enough to maintain the relationship. I felt this guilt for a long time. I would have felt guilty/horrible on some level anyway, but conversations with outsiders (whom I would consider my friends as I didn't go telling my woes to people I hardly knew) certainly made things worse and elongated the learning to live with the reality of the situation even though they had no idea or no way to comprehend the situation, really.

Being "used to" something does not make it healthy for you. "Just words" can often be exceptionally hurtful and emotionally abusive. No one truly becomes "immune" to such things.

Sometimes (not always, of course) people do need to just leave situations behind them when it becomes evident that things will not change. Sometimes "running away" is more like being driven away, etc. Sometimes completely leaving a situation and/or person is the only way to get them/it to STOP controlling your life.

Do I sometimes think about the situation with a twinge of sadness, yes, especially when I hear similar stories or around mother's day. Do I regret my decision; absolutely not. I feel like I made every reasonable effort that could have been made and in the end I did what I had to do to preserve my sanity. Without a doubt I am a happier more healthy person today than I would have been otherwise. And I'm living a life I want to, rather than being controlled and manipulated by someone else.

Clearly not every situation will parallel mine (probably no situation will, some being much worse, some much less severe, and some just different) and many relationships probably can (and should) be saved in some form or another. But to speak in absolutes, to assert that a relationship must/should be maintained, that one should continue to subject them-self to situations that are hurtful to them (even if that situation is words on a page), and to imply that one should be "used to" or "immune" to emotionally abusive and manipulative behavior (intentional or stemming from a documented disorder) simply because the other person is a parent is nothing more than naiveté and, well intentioned as it may be (because I'm sure everything you wrote was very much well intentioned), can add to emotional turmoil, guilt, and depression in people going through these situations.

I'm certainly not advocating that Bmc break all ties with her mom, or even assuming that her relationship with her mom is emotionally abusive (only that it seems evident that the relationship is very hard on her emotionally for whatever reason). But really only Bmc is in a position to understand her relationship, what the issues are, what the intentions are (which ended up being a very big deciding factor for me, personally), and what is the best compromise for her (because most of the time it's a lose-lose situation). Just because one party is a parent doesn't make anything any more cut and dry. In the end we can only offer her a virtual shoulder to lean on. Advice, well, I think Oakleaf said it best. And yes, professional counseling, if feasible, is definitely a path to consider (either on a longer term basis or just a few sessions).

And please, withm, let me reiterate that I in no way believe that you intended anything other than to be helpful, as my friends intended as well. And maybe, being emotionally completely on the other side of this, I'm seeing something more and this will be more helpful than hurtful to Bmc. I hope so as I hope everyone can struggle through and in the end come out with more ideal results than I did. Sure did tug at some painful memories for me though.

Anyway, this has been exceptionally long winded, and I apologize. Just felt the need to voice what the view from "the other side of the street" *can* be.

[Cataboo]

I'd also disagree that running away is somehow letting someone continue to control your life. And that somehow if you're used to someone treating you like ****, you become used to it and immune and that it's okay to be treated like ****. By that logic, all women who are getting beaten by their husbands should just stay in their marriages.

Yes, families are difficult... and as much as possible, people should try to work everything out and do what they can. But the reality is, that sometimes people just suck and just because they're related to you by an accident of birth and genetics and you love them, doesn't mean that you have to keep them in your life or that it's healthy to do so. The fact that someone is related to you doesn't mean they get a pass on their behavior. It does mean you forgive them for more and give them more chances, but at some point, enough is enough.

I could go into details, but hey, I use my real name on the internet

[Selkie]

I wouldn't characterize it as "running away." I think it's more "running to" something more positive and healthy.

The great thing is that we are adults and have choices. That includes the choice to do the right thing for oneself.

[Crankin]

I agree with Martian Destiny. Just because someone is your mother (insert any family member here), doesn't mean you are beholden to endure whatever **** they give you.
As a disclaimer, I will say that my relationship with my parents was good. My mom died almost 15 years ago. I miss her, but, life goes on. I talk to my dad, who lives in CA, but it's not a super close relationship. That's nothing new.
But, I do have some experience with "divorcing" a relative. I "divorced" my aunt (my mom's sister). She always has been the drama queen in my family, with some definite underlying mental health issues. When her DH died at age 52, she pretty much declared her life was over, and took it as a signal to run everyone else's life. This occurred right at the time I moved back here. I was able to be firm with boundaries, and still be with my family for holidays, etc. She was too busy trying to run her own kid's lives. When my mom got sick, she thought I was cruel and heartless for not leaving my own family and going to CA indefinitely. My mom specifically did not want me to do that! My aunt interfered with my mom's medical situation, drove my dad and brother crazy, and generally acted crazy when we ignored her.
Over the years, I tried with her, but she only wanted to tell me what to do. When one cousin became super religious and gave my DH crap about not wearing a yarmulke on Passover and I no longer could take the other cousin, who has always been a xenophobic, gun touting, right winger, I stopped calling. It's been a year and a half, and it is better. I feel badly that my kids have lost contact with the few relatives they have, but they witnessed her craziness growing up, so it's in context. Life is too short.

[Catrin]

My mother has long-term, basically untreated, mental health issues as well. This is so hard to deal with, and I think it is difficult for others who do not have that family dynamic to really understand what this means.

I and my sisters have taken decades to learn how to deal with this in a way that does not harm us, yet allows us to find some way to not cut her out of our lives entirely (though we did for some time). We finally came to understand that she raised us the best way that she could, she just didn't have much to work with and that was just the way it was. It took close to 20 years of total separation for me to come to truly understand that - we had a very rough family life...

Understanding that did help the three of us to come up with our own way to remain in contact with her without, however, participating in the dramatic world that she lives in. It does her no good to play her games, and it certainly isn't good for us. She and I will never have a "traditional" mother/daughter relationship - but I have found ways to stay in touch with her that doesn't fire up the old drama.

You will have to make your decision on how to deal with this - though I do like the approach others have suggested about not accepting the letter and telling her that she just needs to tell you what is going on. The whole certified letter approach is adversarial. For your own sake you need to maintain strong boundaries, and it sounds like she doesn't expect you to have any.

Please keep us posted as you can, you are not alone in this.

[kiwibug]

I am so surprised to see how many people grew up with mothers suffering from mental health illnesses.

I felt really really alone growing up. Even within my family, my mom's bipolar disorder was never talked about, and the horrible periods where she went off her meds were major secrets we never discussed. Luckily psychiatric medicine has done a lot for my mother, she's doing really well and our relationship is loving.

I don't know what would have happened if we hadn't got the illness under control. I maintain that unless you have lived with and loved someone with mental illness, you can't possibly understand. Without experiencing it you can't say that you would never run away, or that one shouldn't.

[Zen]

And here I thought my family put the funk in dysfunctional...what a lot we are here. One thing for sure, there's always a sympathetic ear here and, more often than not, some good advice.

[Bike Chick]

And here I thought my family put the funk in dysfunctional...what a lot we are here. One thing for sure, there's always a sympathetic ear here and, more often than not, some good advice.

Zen, you always make me laugh Ditto!

[TrekTheKaty]

And here I thought my family put the funk in dysfunctional...what a lot we are here.

Amen, Zen. In college, I had a group of friends that realized we all had dysfunctional families except one person. We thought HE should be on Oprah, since he insisted that his childhood was "Leave it to Beaverish!"

I posed the question to my sister a few years ago: "Maybe we are the crazy ones and every one else is normal?" I was serious. She cackled like a wild woman and poured me another glass of wine

Just a thought (are these walls rubber?)

[TrekTheKaty]

In the meantime it might help to examine carefully why this upsets you so. You know what to expect from your mother. Clearly she has not changed after what 30-40-50 years? By now you ought to be used to, if not immune, to her behavioral quirks an and just chalk it up to "my crazy mother."

I would have to respectfully disagree with this statement. In my personal situation, I am sure my stepmother could could dissolve the self esteem it took me 20 years to reestablish with a glance. I don't give her the opportunity.

I admire shootingstar for reaching out for support from her cyberfriends. If she was friend from my hometown, I would meet her for coffee, a hug and just to listen. She needs our support. I hope our suggestions haven't confused her even more, but what are sisters for?

[shootingstar]

I would have to respectfully disagree with this statement. In my personal situation, I am sure my stepmother could could dissolve the self esteem it took me 20 years to reestablish with a glance. I don't give her the opportunity.

I admire shootingstar for reaching out for support from her cyberfriends. If she was friend from my hometown, I would meet her for coffee, a hug and just to listen. She needs our support. I hope our suggestions haven't confused her even more, but what are sisters for?

Perhaps you meant bccmsland who originally asked for people's opinions/ideas? Not that myself and 5 siblings have problem with a mother who is quite controlling, on top of the linguistic gap..I just haven't bothered to get into details 'cause I really don't expect many people here to experience high family conflict due to linguistic gaps, on top of major personality weakness in a parent.

But it's ok. We'll survive..though we're worried now with my father having cancer..he the language intepreter, family mediator..etc. Certain things are better, other things not and never will be.
I'm not a mother and I question myself if i could have been a good mother. Honest.