You guys are awesome!

I was initially going to go with Keo Pedals (look style), but according to LBS, they've had problems with the cleats fitting on shoes under size 40 properly (I have Bontrager RL Road WSD in 38.5). They suggested the speedplays.

I'll try loosening the screws and see if that works. LBS installed the cleats and I didn't test before leaving. Dumb, I know. Never again!

In the meantime, hubby has removed my spd pedals from my 'cross bike so I'll have them just in case.