I have a surly cross-check, but my first love was the long haul trucker. The only reason I got the cross-check is because I couldn't get the 700cc wheels on a 50cm long haul, but could get them on a cross-check. If you don't have to worry about the size issue, I'd recommend the long haul. Its got a smooth, steady ride on the road, the cross-check is more nimble which for me translates into less stable ride.