Hey, Amanda, that song is "In Spite of Ourselves" sung by John Prine and Iris DeMent.

John Prine is one of my faves for snappy, bouncy little tunes that stick in my head ("Leave the Lights On" always cracks me up). 'Course, a lot of his songs will also break your heart.

Leave the Lights On (first verse):

Feeling kind of bony
On the telephoney
Talking to Marconi
Eating Rice-a-Roni
Nominated for a Tony
For acting like a phoney
Watching Twilight Zoney
On my forty-two inch Sony
This is just a long song
It ain't no poem
Leave the lights on till your baby gets home


PS I love-love-love They Might Be Giants!!! That whole album (Flood) is one gem after another.