First come first serve seems most fair. If we do this based on weather, I'm in the land of below-zero temperatures galore - which, actually has me wondering if toe covers would be best for moderately cold weather (like WY). It seems to me that the more extreme winter folks, like myself, would be best served by the full foot/ankle coverage of winter cycling booties - rather than just toe covers. (Not that I'd pass them up if you offered them )

Regardless, it's very nice of you to be offering them free. You could easily return them or sell them on eBay, so thank you for your kindness. Good karma is on its way.