I've been reading this thread with interest as I've developed a pain after I run (treadmill or trails). The pain is in my right toe, down low at the base, in the joint I guess, more on top of the foot than underneath the toe. None at all in my left foot. I don't feel it while running, but only when walking around afterwards.

My shoes are good New Balance 754 running shoes (not very old). I do not have any kind of insert other than what came in the shoes. I have rigid, underpronating feet so went for the "cushioning" type of shoe as opposed to the stability type. I went up a half-size from my street shoes after a bout of black toenail in my left big toe last year from wearing too-small running shoes just a couple of times. These shoes seem plenty long and have an ample toe box. My feet are medium width.

Any ideas of what this pain could be? It usually lasts for a day or two after a run, then goes away, only to return after the next run. Would Superfeet possibly help, or is a trip to a PT or podiatrist in my future?

Thanks!
Emily