I am wondering what your bike positions are too. I went with the Finesse on my dry weather bike and will probably get a Team Pro S for my 3 season bike. The seat is shaped so that one's weight should even out comfortably when riding in the drops. Both these saddles are recommended for those who like to spend a fair amount of time in the drops.

As it is mentioned all over the Brooks thread, it can take alot of patience and adjusting to get the sweet spot. When I first get a Brooks I tilt the nose up slightly to counteract the initial slipperiness of the saddle.

Then again, Brooks aren't for everyone either.