Another bike fashion question

[Grits]

As I sit here with my broken foot, I am thinking about what I want to do with the colors on my bike.

It came with these really ugly tires (not in stock picture) with an off-white strip on one side that don't look good with the pure white trim on the bike, so I want to replace those and have about enough mileage to justify it now. I have replaced the white saddle with a black one.

It also has the white handlebar tape that I want to get rid of for practical reasons. I either want to tone it down and just go basic black, or add a nice contrasting color. But what to do with the kind of teal/aqua color?

If I could find the EXACT right shade of teal for the bar tape, that would be good, and just do black tires. Or, go for it and add contrasting bar tape (pink? orange?) and tires with a color stripe. Any advice?