Quote Originally Posted by lunacycles View Post
Yes, but you want your bike to be able to do this, should you be in one of your less clear/ more tired moments and accidentally make that shift. If the chain is too short and you accidentally shift "big-big" while riding, it can literally rip the derailleur off the frame, potentially destroying your frame, at a minimum destroying the derailleur. A longer chain also just shifts better.
This is true, but it is easy to have too long of a chain on a compact if the chainstays are relatively short. That's because when in the small/large combo, you don't have enough chain tension to pull the RD away from the sprockets. With some setups, tightening the Bscrew to its max won't fix that. So, to avoid that, the chain will be a tad short and noisy. But, it shouldn't be shortened so much that the RD is being pulled sharply forward when in the big/big. You still need enough chain wrap to reach this gear and sustain a bit of an S shape in the RD, even if it's noisy.