I have never heard of a restocking fee for a local bike shop. I have for ordering it, if they don't carry it. I would definitely challenge that. Call anonymously and ask how to contact the owner. Tell him about your experience and that you are not happy with your purchase, but returning the bike would turn out to be too expensive. I bet he would be willing to work something out. From what I have seen about bike shop owners, they love the sport and wouldn't want to be responsible for someone having a bad experience.

Good Luck,

Jen L