Kim,
Here's the ingredients in Bag Balm:
Ingredients: 8-Hydroxyquinoline Sulfate 0.3% in a petrolatum lanolin base.
Another good lubricant for saddle comfort is Assos Chamois Creme. It's my personal favorite, but I've used Bag Balm and Chamois Butt'r, too, and they all work pretty well........ The Assos stuff isn't cheap but it is very nice.
Here's the list of ingredients, direct from the jar:
Deonized water, glycerine, propylene glycol,decyl oleate, polydecene, witch hazel extract, almond oil, sorbitan stearate, menthol, cyclomethicone, oak bark extract, methylparaben, retinol, palminate, BHA.
I never looked at the ingredients till now. What a long list! I don't know what some of them are or what they are supposed to do, I just know I like the stuff. The directions say to rub it directly onto the chamois of your shorts and rub it in. Or may be applied directly to skin. I've tried both methods and either one is fine.
A and D ointment, isn't that for diaper rash? It doesn't smell all that great, but neither does bag balm. If it works, it's worth the stink. The chamois cremes made for biking wash out of the shorts easily. Bag Balm seems to, also. I don't know about something like A and D.
I don't know if any of them would work as a moisture barrier. Too much movement to keep a barrier intact. They all work as lubricants to cut down on the amount of friction, thereby reducing chafing and rubbing.
Good luck in finding one you like and good to see you back on the boards!!!
Time is a companion that goes with us on a journey. It reminds us to cherish each moment, because it will never come again. What we leave behind is not as important as how we have lived." Captain Jean Luc Picard