Hi,
I was just reading your post and no, I haven't ridden on the saddle you discuss, but I noticed I had problems similar to the ones you describe. I was wondering if you ever thought about the width of the nose on the saddle? I have found a narrower width of the nose has helped me and alleviated a lot of the front soft-tissue discomfort I have had (I have had luck with the men's Flite and men's pro-link saddles by Selle Italia, but that's what has worked for me personally.).
You might not need a WSD saddle. It took me almost 7 years to realize that. Everyone has different widths obviously of their pelvises, but you can take two people with the same width of pelvis and the spacing of their sit bones (ischial tuberosities) can be different. This is one of the many factors that determines which type of saddle you like. I also discovered that for me personally, I couldn't stand the saddles that are too cushy or soft...it seemed counterintutive at the time, but now, I wouldn't go back to a mushy saddle for anything.
Also, it takes some time to break in your bike's saddle, so you could possibly like it more with more riding and some minor adjustments on your bike fit. You might want to schedule a bike fit with a reputable person and they can let you try different saddles, stems, handlebars, etc. while checking your alignment and fit. Just remember that saddles feel differently on the trainer than they do while riding. Also, if you know of any guys and gals with different saddles, you might want to borrow them and just get a general feel for what you like on a test ride. (I stole my husband's, for instance).
I have noticed that having my saddle level has helped as well. One thing I discovered is that having my handlebars up higher did help alleviate both my hand and wrist pain as well as many of my saddle issues. When I got my new road bike, I made sure they didn't cut the steerer tube so I could have more heighth in my handle bars. (I am not sure if they can do this with mtn. bikes?) But, you can get a stem with a bit of a rise as well. You might be able to play with the stem length as well, as well as the fore/aft position of the saddle.
Also, if you have a shorter torso and longer legs, the top tube length might be an issue. Once I switched to a shorter top tube road bike, I was able to quit playing that game of alternating my weight (either my wrists/hands would hurt or my front soft-tissue...which was very frustrating).
Also, the width of your handlebars can affect the comfort of your hands and even your saddle comfort. With a mountain bike, you might want to experiment with different grips or maybe bring your brakes in closer, for instance as a couple of things that can help with hand comfort.
Just be sure to make your bike fit changes gradually. Bike fit is so dynamic and things definitely can change. I always make even my equipment changes in small increments. So, say, I get a new saddle, I only ride it for a half hour at a time, so I can get used to it. Or, if I move my saddle more forward or back, I only move it in mm's, not inches, so that it doesn't cause any problems with the rest of my body. Just making one little change can affect the whole body (you are probably aware though of this).
Sorry this was long. Hope that you can get your saddle issues figured out so you can have many happy miles
![]()
Sincerely,
Lisa