OK, I want to start off by saying this is a ridiculous first world problem. Not just that, it's a middle class first world problem. But I'm bringing it up because I am struggling.

If you had to choose between .6 acres, 3 miles to work, amazingly cute small house, but on a very busy street (logging trucks going 50 mph) or 6 miles (including a very big hill) from work, 4 acres, secluded, world class riding right off of your property but a house that needed a ton of work before you could even move in...

What would you choose?

The price is essentially the same.