hello, this is my first post on this forum. I seem to get directed here whenever I google about bike seats, so I might as well stick around!

I need some input on bike saddles. I currently commute on my cyclocross with an Avocet o2 saddle. It's done me well for the last couple of years, but since it's that synthetic buffalo "leather" it's frayed beyond pathetic now. I really need to replace it, but it's so difficult when everyone's shaped differently and most stores won't let you try them out anymore.

I've recently tried a Terry ATB Comp and found it to be one of the most uncomfortable pieces of bricks shaped like a saddle; I'm numb in minutes.

I'm fairly small, and my sit bones are quite narrow. I'm contemplating a Brooks B-17, but am a bit scared about the initial break in phase.

Any suggestions? thanks!