Hi GirlWonder,

I had the same dilema when I was bike shopping. I tried the 47 (WSD)and to me it felt too big because I didn't have much clearance over the top tube. So I went to another shop and they suggested I try the 44(WSD). I rode it around the parking lot but I was really scrunched on it. I felt like I was on a kid's bike. The sales person where I tried the 44 insisted that they could fit it properly but I didn't like the feel. I went back to the first store and tried the 47 (Trek Pilot WSD) again and the salesperson there (different person than first time) explained how the fit works. I ended up buying the 47 with a shortened stem, adjusted seat, and shims in the brakes. Not that I have a lot of experience but after 700 miles on it, I feel that it fits me just right.

This may work differently for you. I suggest you at least try out the 44 before jumping in.

Good luck,
Patty