Quote Originally Posted by bikeless in WI
My $0.02 worth (which are worth less than those of more experienced riders) ...
You'd be amazed at the difference between saddles! My "comfort" saddle doesn't feel so comfortable either any more, now that I've found a narrow one that fits my sit bones and isn't in the way of my inner thighs when pedalling. So I suggest you find a good bike shop where you can try some different saddles. It may be that the comfort seat is simply too wide. (I'm just looking for a bike now that deserves that saddle I found )

Also ... chamois is very different from garment to garment, so try some different shorts while you're at it and find one with a chamois that stays put, doesn't bunch up, and doesn't interfere with your spin motion. There ARE different +-sized shorts out there. I know, 'cuz I wear 'em too.

And finally, yes, chamois butter does help. I've got that on my shopping list now. I've been ok for short rides without, but I have a longer ride coming up and, thanks again to more experienced riders (that'd be you, Trek420), I know I'll need chamois butter for that one.
I'm with Bikeless. Chamois butter does help, I never used it before this year but now I use it each time I ride more than 4 miles.
I have been through a lot of seats too, and have settled on the Brooks B67.

the wear under your sitting bones is proof of how long you are in the saddle. Let us know what you end up doing
I own 4 saddles for my 1 bike now. I know i am not alone.
m