Thank you all, I'm taking your advice. I went with the women's Sidi Genius 5's and the Look KeO Carbon pedals. I have another century in a couple of weeks, so hopefully I will have broken them in nicely by then.

I'll put my lovely Genius 5.5 HT's back in the shipping box and return them to TE, hoping for a brighter future in which Sidi starts making women's shoes in other colors... heheh.

For the MTB I'm going to stick with my SPD pedals, since I have the ones with the resin cage which gives me a nice little platform. Also I'd like to get back into spinning and most of the gyms here use SPD pedals, so it saves me from having to have separate shoes for that. But I'll definitely keep the Time ATACs in mind if I ever consider changing. I have several friends who swear by them.

~Cari