Peanut butter - what am I doing wrong?

[OakLeaf]

My dogs figured out how to suck the peanut butter off the pill and spit the pill out anyway

[WindingRoad]

I'm late to the party here but I was at Fresh Thyme grocery the other day and they actually have peanut butter, almond and cashew butter they grind themselves with not additives other than oil.

[ny biker]

I've been able to reduce the mess of stirring by turning the jar upside down in the pantry for a few days before I open it.

Not sure if I mentioned this already, but when there's only a little left in the jar and it's dried out, my friend suggested warming it up (jar and all) in the microwave to soften it.