I'd wait for the HDL/LDL breakdown. How are your triglyceride levels?

I am neither a doctor nor a pharmacist, but if you've got a healthy diet and minimal risk factors for heart disease outside the cholesterol (and that depends on your HDL/LDL), then the statin is your choice to take or not. While I'm all for better living through chemistry when appropriate, I'm also all for not taking something if you don't have to. You could try going vegetarian for a month or so, but my guess is that the source of your cholesterol isn't necessarily dietary.

(The risk of muscle issues with statins, if I'm remembering my pharmacology class properly, is pretty low.)