My hubby just got a pair of these from REI and really likes them. The biggest beef is that the liner is not removable. But otherwise very comfy and lots of pockets for Jelly Bellies and such. He tried on at least 20 pairs (OK, I exaggerate...) but he liked the fit of these the best.

Of course, shorts are personal...if you have an REI nearby, take him down there and run him through the racks.