Cycling panties, yay or nay?

[Eden]

nay... the undie style negates a lot of the utility of having a chamois - IMHO they'd at least need to be "boy shorts" length and tight enough around the leg hole to stay put to be of any use. Both those pairs look like they might rub in uncomfortable places. She looks like she's been sucked into the "padding" myth of cycling shorts.... it's not about padding anything (in fact as many people find out highly padded shorts can be a major liability for soft tissue pressure and discomfort), but about creating a seamless place for your tender parts to be gliding along on... puts on querulous oldster voice.... I remember when cycling shorts had real chamois leather in them and weren't padded in the slightest (ok, ok... I never had a pair with real chamois, but I did have some with a synthetic, washable, equivalent that were basically unpadded)

[marni]

actually, aside from the vintage aspect of look and fabric, Novarra already makes a panty type brief with a chamois in black and white. They are not extremely thick chamois, but there is enough for commuting on anything other than a really hard saddle. I wore them for several years while commuting for work and to the gym but always took a pair of regular briefs to change into and out of and used them only for the ride. I still wear them at the gym because they are more comfortable than cotton or nylon briefs under my work out shorts and or tights.

[kris7047th]

Found this. REI does have a brief, but the reviews are poor with the padding too far back.

These fare far better .. http://www.rei.com/product/845303/no...derwear-womens

[rebeccaC]

Thinking sexualization is a lazy marketing technique that is already too prevalent and something that just turns me away from a product. This product may work for some and it's their call on the way it's being marketed.

[Grits]

I forget the brand, but I have a padded pair of underwear that I got years ago from REI. It isn't the one linked above. I wear them sometimes to spin class. I've never had a problem with chafing. I think for a ride less than an hour, which I guess most commutes are, they would be fine, if you need padding for a ride that short. As long as the chamois is removable for the day, or you bring an extra pair of undies anyway, they should be fine. They certainly are more attractive than the pair I have, or any of my underwear, for that matter!

[Crankin]

I tend to wear the liner shorts for short errand rides. I cannot sit on a bike without a chamois. Even the liner shorts don't work that well for rides over 5 miles. And, my regular shorts are not super padded (Terry Bellas and Sugoi).
I bought a pair of padded underpants from TE quite a few years ago. They were huge granny panties; there was no x small so I got smalls (my azz is not that petite). They went in the trash after a few attempts at riding in them.
When I commuted (13.8 miles), I wore regular cycling clothes.