Balls of feet keep cramping up

[Donna1960]

Oakleaf I have the "lollipop" pedals which was by his suggestion...

[rebeccaC]

Oakleaf I have the "lollipop" pedals which was by his suggestion...

Donna, I use speedplay's and they work fine for me. Sometimes with a smaller pedal you can get problems, hot spots etc., from mashing so I spin more than mash. If you're confident in the position of the cleat then have the fitter look at your pedal stroke too. Again I'll mention orthotic insoles if the problem persists after you're sure of the shoe/cleat fit and position and pedal stroke is okay. I have a wide foot too and found Carnac's to work well for me.

[Donna1960]

I'll do that Rebecca...thanks for the help!

[Donna1960]

I have tried loosening them as much as possible...if inserts are inexpensive I will try them too. Just a little discouraged because I thought going clipless would be such a great improvement over my toe clips which I never had discomfort with...*sigh*....hoping I can get it all figured out before the century I am planning in a few weeks...

[OakLeaf]

Are you wearing the same shoes you were when you used toe clips? Are you *sure* they're wide enough? I have wide feet too, and IME loosening the fasteners does nothing when the soles of your feet are wider than the soles of your shoes. The parts of your forefoot that are supposed to be weightbearing - the first and fifth metatarsal heads - are hanging over the edge at best (and getting irritated and turning into bunions at worst). The middle bones, that are supposed to be lifting your transverse arch, instead wind up bearing weight and causing all kinds of trouble with your foot mechanics.

If you're not sure, pull the insoles out and stand on them. If any part of your foot is hanging over the edge of the insole, your shoes are too narrow.

Yeah, I have wide feet, and I know WAY too much about this stuff. Sigh.

But those lollipop pedals are pretty small, too. A small platform kind of winds up doing the same thing, especially if your shoe has any flex to it at all - putting the weight onto the second and third metatarsal heads and making it hard for the outer bones to bear weight. I know swapping pedals is an expensive fix, but you might try Look, which is what I've always ridden.

Also, what kinds of foot exercises are you doing off the bike? Yoga? Toe skrunches? Myofascial release by rolling out or walking on pebbles? Other?

[Crankin]

I've been using Speedplay for years. I did have this problem, but it was from wearing Sidis that were too narrow for my average width foot. Then, when I got my new Shimano shoes, the special molded to your own foot insert was so thick and awful (my LBS thought I was nuts), I wore my shoes for 2 weeks without any inersoles, and then went out and got the blue Superfeet ones. I need thin, thin, thin inersoles. I seem to have this issue with my hands, too, hence the need for gloves with no padding or gel. I can't stand anything thick or tight on my extremeties when riding, as it causes immediate pain and swelling, even in cool weather. Not swelling that is visible, no medical cause. Problem solved.
I do get the hot spot a bit, still, with my mtb style shoes and Frog cleats, but only on 40+ mile rides, on the foot with a bunion. But, it was much worse with spd style pedals that had a platform.

[Donna1960]

Oakleaf...I wore good ole sneakers with my toe clips. The shoes are brand new along with the pedals. When I put them on there feels to be plenty of room in them which leads me to beleive that the fit is proper. The shoes are very stiff. I just spent 115 on the pedals and 150 on the shoes. Money that I really didn't have to begin with so I need to try and make this work with as little as possible additional expense but more importantly without damage to my feet..

When I go for my ride tomorrow I will try them without any insoles and see what happens. Thanks everyone for your replies. I'll keep you posted

Off the bike foot exercises? I have never done any.....