I like Paleo Comfort Foods. I think it's my second favorite after Well Fed and slightly ahead of Everyday Paleo (because the photography is way better). I was actually expecting not to really use it all that much because most 'comfort foods' just don't appeal to me. BUT, the book has tons of recipes for basics like ketchup, tortillas, nut based pie crusts, etc. Every thing I've made from the cookbook has been excellent. There is a paleo chili that uses two different cuts of beef that is really wonderful. And a sweet potato pie that I took to work for the holidays and all the non-paleo people raved about! There is also a delicious spiced nuts recipe that was a big hit at our last party, too.

I think the assortment of recipes is similar to Make it Paleo and the photography is of the same excellent quality, but I've never had a dud from Paleo Comfort foods and I've had two of them from Make it Paleo (where the recipe failed...not that we just didn't like it).

I don't have Practical Paleo though, so I can't compare it to that one. (yet) Oh, and I haven't made anything from the Cavemen e-cookbook either - nothing inspired me!