Gear Acquisition Syndrome...love it!

When I started riding again last spring I used to refer to my saddle as a torture device. It honestly felt like I was sitting on a 2x4! I'd get on my old hybrid bike for a quickie ride and the saddle was so much more comfy. After a while I forgot all about my saddle being uncomfortable. A couple of weeks ago I pulled out my old hybrid and took it for a spin. Yeowch!!! That saddle wasn't so comfy anymore, it was squishy and smashing the bits! I realized that the saddle I used to refer to as a 2x4 was so much more comfortable. I realize now that my sit bones just needed to acclimate to being back on a saddle after a long period off the bike. YMMV, but I would give your current saddle some more time out on the road before switching to something else.