Bringing this back to say thanks to everyone for the advice! I've narrowed it down to two Felts-- the ZW75 and a 2010 ZW5. Both are on year-end sale. I'm almost ready to pull the trigger on the ZW5, which has been discounted a lot.

Something else I'm thinking: would it be weird for me to try to bargain with the LBS if we buy two bikes there? DH has been thinking about a Jamis...