Celebrating a new commuter bike

[ZenBiker]

Thanks everyone!

IBrakeforPastry, I'm trying to limit myself to 2 bikes at any one time but it's hard when they are all so pretty and so much fun to test ride!

Muirenn, I went into the shop to ride a Surly but he didn't have my size frame in stock - only had the one above and below what I needed. So I rode both of those and liked the bigger of the two, but could barely stand over it. So then he rolls out the Salsa and you can see what happened.

Devold, it's a 50 so it has the 26" wheels. The 52 would probably fit me better, at least according to the Salsa website, and my only lingering doubt/regret is that I didn't hold out for a chance to ride a 52 and compare. But the closest bike shop that even carries Surly and Salsa is a 3-hour drive for me, and I was only in town for the day, and the 50 felt pretty good...and anyway, as you said, the 52 has 26" wheels too.

So far I don't feel like I gave up much by having smaller wheels. There is less toe overlap than with my 700c road bike and while the Salsa isn't a speed machine, i can maintain a respectable pace very easily once I get going.

Edited to add: the guy at the shop showed me an article by Rivendell that gave a bunch of reasons they will only use 26" wheels on smaller frames - had to do with seat tube angles and other things they considered unacceptable geometry compromises when putting bigger wheels on such frames. I don't have the knowledge or experience to critically evaluate the things they said, but it sounded pretty convincing.

[Devold]

Devold, it's a 50 so it has the 26" wheels. The 52 would probably fit me better, at least according to the Salsa website, and my only lingering doubt/regret is that I didn't hold out for a chance to ride a 52 and compare. But the closest bike shop that even carries Surly and Salsa is a 3-hour drive for me, and I was only in town for the day, and the 50 felt pretty good...and anyway, as you said, the 52 has 26" wheels too.

So far I don't feel like I gave up much by having smaller wheels. There is less toe overlap than with my 700c road bike and while the Salsa isn't a speed machine, i can maintain a respectable pace very easily once I get going.

Edited to add: the guy at the shop showed me an article by Rivendell that gave a bunch of reasons they will only use 26" wheels on smaller frames - had to do with seat tube angles and other things they considered unacceptable geometry compromises when putting bigger wheels on such frames. I don't have the knowledge or experience to critically evaluate the things they said, but it sounded pretty convincing.

Thanks, it sounds promising I also read some stuff about why they chose smaller wheels. The 50 and 52 are SMALL frames and I hate to much toe overlap!

I hope you'll enjoy your new bike :-)