Ok, I'm going to look for a new helmet. There are so many to choose from though! I liked the looks of the Giro Eclipse, as the profile was a good fit for my face, but it's a bit loose. Barrelgal, it was weird - I had it in the smallest setting and while the fit wasn't loose, I felt like I could still shift it around, meaning it wasn't snug.

I think the wheel tightening feature has helped improve this though, since the helmets I borrowed for the test rides all fit when I adjusted them.

Any good suggestions for small profile helmets? With my small face I feel a little like Toad from the Mario Brothers with some of the helmets.

I've used Bell and Giro in the past and I'm not quite as worried about the head fit with the wheel adjustment. I've done some searching and do not wish to go beyond $90 at this point... I'll go to the stores this week.