Felt entry level (ZW100 at the time) was my first "adult" bike that wasn't a hand-me-down from my brothers. Felts for me had a good ride and you get a nice bike for the price. I'd suggest the ZW95 or if your budget can handle it, the ZW75 (with SRAM Apex). Also consider the Cannondale Synapse Aluminum Tiagra ($1,280).

Lots of great suggestions by the other posters, too. The Bianchi Via Nirone 7 Dama 105 is incredibly sweet. *drooling on keyboard*

Sounds like you have some fun test riding to do this weekend!