Update: I've had my B17 for about 400 miles, and after a couple very minor adjustments, I can say I love it. The longest ride I've done is 40 miles, so I can't yet say it's perfect, but I found it comfortable from the get-go, and moreso now. It's just starting to get the indents where my sit bones rest. I'm looking forward to finding out if it gets even more comfy.
2013 Kirk Frameworks JK Special/Selle Anatomica
2012 Gunnar Sport/Brooks B17
2001 Calfee Tetra Pro/Selle Anatomica
1984 Raleigh Sport/Brooks B66