OK, I think it's the touring jacket.
I got to test it on a run yesterday. It was 52 and I had a thin, regular LS wicking shirt on under it. Now, remember, you get much hotter running than riding. I had the pit zips open and I definitely could feel the wind through the vented back. But, I started to feel sweaty and took the jacket off and tied it around my waist. The rain had actually stopped. It started misting again later on the run, but not enough to put the jacket back on.
I think this would be perfect for riding in the rain. Definitely less clammy than my other rain jackets. I wouldn't want to wear it when it was really hot out, but most likely it's going to be less than 70 if I get caught in the rain. If it's hotter, it's probably going to be thundering and I would find shelter!
I have real rain pants. They do make you sweat, but they saved my azz on my first tour, in the Czech Republic. It was in the 50s and pouring for the first 2 days.