New clipless shoes and pedals...but....

[Crankin]

I use road pedals on my road bike and Speedlay Frogs on my road/touring bike.

[ToshaMack]

I got the Shimano M540 SPD. I went for a morning ride and was pleasantly surprised. Knock on some wood… I didn’t fall, but was very conscious of stopping and starting. I did notice that one shoe was awful tight; when I checked the sizes I found I had two different shoe sizes.

[Biciclista]

a lot of us use MTB shoes and cleats on our road bikes. We like to be able to walk.

[emily_in_nc]

I'm another who used "mountain" pedals (Crankbeaters Candy SL) on my road bike, along with Keen sandals. Loved being able to get off the bike and walk around a market. I used to use Speedplay X series back in my serious road-riding days, and those were a pain to walk in! So, no, I don't think your LBS guy steered you wrong at all.

[Owlie]

I got the Shimano M540 SPD. I went for a morning ride and was pleasantly surprised. Knock on some wood… I didn’t fall, but was very conscious of stopping and starting. I did notice that one shoe was awful tight; when I checked the sizes I found I had two different shoe sizes.

I have those pedals exactly. For the money, they're pretty nice.

Hopefully you can take the shoes back and get that sorted out!