Thank you, tzvia and nscrbug for your helpful replies. Apologize for my delayed response.

I checked the Bontager bar (Bontrager WSD VR OS?) online but it was out of stock pretty much everywhere for the size and color I was looking for. I ended up getting the 36/38 mm 3T Ergonova Pro. It made a huge difference in terms of riding comfort. I did not know how uncomfortable I was with the 40mm Specialized Comp Ergo bar until I made the switch.

Reaching the brifters in the drop had always been kind of a struggle with the old bar but now it is effortless. I am now able to stay in the drop most of the time without having my arms feeling splayed out. Also, there is no more shoulder pain and hand numbness on longer rides.

Thanks again for the helpful tips!! = )