If you remove the pain from squished bits from the equation, does the new position feel otherwise feel better or worse? If the new position feels better, then you should probably start by looking at other saddles. If there are other problems with the position, then you need to re-visit the person who made the changes, list out the issues and get things tweaked.
2009 BMC Road Racer SL 01 / Specialized Ruby 155
2007 LeMond Reno / Luna Chix Team Saddle
1980-something Lotus Odyssey / Brooks Finesse
1992 Bridgestone RB-2 / Brooks B-17 Imperial
Nada Bike singlespeed / Brooks Team Pro in white