Thanks Kirsten! I decided to try the New England one, it was a) cheapest and b) eligible for free returns and c) the only small! So we'll see what happens. Crossing fingers. So many of my current jerseys were clearance sale items and are just too thin, have to wear something under them. Once I bought your "reject" jerseys I saw what I had been doing was allll wrong! What I get for being a pennypinch...