No experience with the ones you asked about, but I've shipped my carbon bike seven or eight times in my Thule case - once in a round-trip air trip, the other times by FedEx.
Taking your RD off is no big deal at all, and it's really safest to do it. It's pretty vulnerable sticking out there from the frame. Just a 5 mm Allen key and I've never needed to adjust it after re-installing. Easier than taking the pedals off (which you will definitely need to do).
You do want to have dropout spacers - your LBS probably has some lying around, that came on bikes shipped to them. EPS pipe insulation helps protect the tubing, and I had an old convoluted foam mattress topper that I cut up to put on top of the wheels, and to wrap various other things in (including the RD).
Touch wood - but I've not had any problems yet.
It depends on your frame size, handlebar bends, etc. - you may or may not be able to get the bike in the case without removing the seatpost and turning/removing the bars - but the more you disassemble, the easier and safer it will all go into the box.
Packing takes a bit of care, but I've reassembled my bike in 20 minutes in the FedEx parking lot.![]()



Reply With Quote

