I'm also tiny-handed. But I also have large wrists, so velcro closures (that I barely fasten) are a must on any gloves I wear.

My favorite glove is the Potenza Pave in a XS. They have a fairly lightly padded white leather palm, silver lycra back and black terry cloth thumb. And, they're cheap! I can usually find them at my LBS for a little less than $10. On the one occasion I couldn't find my size at my local shop, I found some online for about $8.

I'm still on the hunt for a full-fingered glove that fits the short length of my stubby fingers without being too tight around the base of said stubby fingers.