Since you are having some relative success with the Toupe, I would say to try either the Specialized Ruby or Jett saddles in the same size - 143. Most Specialized shops have a 30-day return policy (at least the 1 shop near me does) as long as the saddle is BLACK. They won't let you return a white one. That is where I would start. FWIW, I'm currently riding on a Ruby 155 for about a year now.