Alcohol didn't do the trick, but I appreciate all the great suggestions. I will check out the other chamois products with the tea tree oil. I did write to the company and let them know the problem I had, and they wrote back within the hour, really impressive. I probably used too much product, they recommend a very fine film applied directly to the skin. I am used to using big gobs of the stuff... To me more is better, but maybe not this time!