So I'm back to this. My right foot has been extra annoyed of late AND I'm starting to get numbness in that foot even when I'm not on the bike. I picked-up a pair of Northwave "Shiver" MTN bike shoes...they are nice, but still a hair too narrow AND my heel slips out of them, so back they're going to have to go.

I guess my next option is men's shoes, since Northwaves appear to be the widest women's shoes out there.

I guess now my issue is finding a men's shoe that has narrow heels. Something for "duck feet." Any suggestions? I'm limited in my ability to try things on locally, unfortunately, since most bike shops are a minimum of an hour away and I'm guessing my 39ish feet are not going to be a commonly stocked size in men's models...