No you're not crazy. I am having problems finding a saddle that really works for me. I raced on my Terry Butterfly this season and experienced a lot of problems. My front, soft-tissue "seated area" would get really bruised on rides with lots of seated climbing. And then if I didn't slather on the Chamois Butt'r I'd develop nasty cysts. I tried tilting the nose down but then just kept sliding towards the front so that didn't help.
I recently threw in the towel and put on the saddle that came with my bike. It's some Bontrager gel thing w/o a cutout and oddly it's actually working much better for me but I'm still not completely happy.
I'll try putting my Butterfly back on and moving the saddle up a bit to see if that solves the problem but I'm not overly optimistic about it.
-Wenona